| Awards |
| Selbold Hawks | Most offensive points per season 2017 (535) |
| Selbold Hawks | Most offensive points per season 2018 (402) |
| Selbold Hawks | Most offensive points per season 2019 (394) |
| Selbold Hawks | Most offensive points per season 2022 (357) |
| Selbold Hawks | Most offensive points per season 2023 (454) |
| Selbold Hawks | Most offensive points per season 2026 (465) |
| Selbold Hawks | Most offensive points per season 2027 (417) |
| Selbold Hawks | Most offensive points per season 2028 (471) |
| Selbold Hawks | Most offensive points per season 2048 (443) |
| Selbold Hawks | Most offensive points per season 2049 (464) |
| Selbold Hawks | Most offensive points per season 2053 (607) |
| Selbold Hawks | Most offensive points per season 2054 (618) |
| Selbold Hawks | Most offensive points per season 2055 (609) |
| Selbold Hawks | Most offensive points per season 2056 (557) |
| Selbold Hawks | Most offensive points per season 2060 (519) |
| Selbold Hawks | Most offensive points per season 2061 (443) |
| Selbold Hawks | Best points against per season 2026 (182) |
| Selbold Hawks | Best points against per season 2031 (144) |
| Selbold Hawks | Best points against per season 2032 (109) |
| Selbold Hawks | Best points against per season 2036 (174) |
| Selbold Hawks | Best points against per season 2038 (150) |
| Selbold Hawks | Best points against per season 2040 (146) |
| Selbold Hawks | Best points against per season 2048 (183) |
| Selbold Hawks | Best points against per season 2051 (175) |
| Selbold Hawks | Best points against per season 2058 (188) |
| Selbold Hawks | Best points against per season 2061 (211) |
| Selbold Hawks | Best points against per season 2067 (175) |
| Selbold Hawks | Best points against per season 2068 (143) |
| Alton Hardman | Most passing yards per season 2049 (4374) |
| Alton Hardman | Most passing yards per season 2053 (4801) |
| Alton Hardman | Most passing TDs per season 2049 (38) |
| Alton Hardman | Most passing TDs per season 2053 (52) |
| Alton Hardman | Best Passing Percentage single season ever (81.6% - PassAtt: 414) |
| James Ryan | Best Passing Percentage per season 2037 (64.9% - PassAtt: 370) |
| Alton Hardman | Best Passing Percentage per season 2049 (73.5% - PassAtt: 468) |
| Alton Hardman | Best Passing Percentage per season 2054 (81.6% - PassAtt: 414) |
| Eusebio Peroff | Best Passing Percentage per season 2060 (75.9% - PassAtt: 398) |
| Eusebio Peroff | Best Passing Percentage per season 2068 (67.9% - PassAtt: 489) |
| Eusebio Peroff | Best Passing Percentage per season 2069 (65.8% - PassAtt: 424) |
| John Rutledge | Best Passing Percentage per season 2073 (70.7% - PassAtt: 375) |
| David Tscrious | Best Passing Percentage per season 2076 (72.5% - PassAtt: 502) |
| David Tscrious | Best Passing Percentage per season 2077 (69.5% - PassAtt: 397) |
| David Tscrious | Best Passing Percentage per season 2082 (75.9% - PassAtt: 369) |
| Jesse Franch | Best Passing Rating per season 2017 (114.1) |
| Jesse Franch | Best Passing Rating per season 2018 (92.4) |
| Jay Vail | Best Passing Rating per season 2022 (99.0) |
| Jay Vail | Best Passing Rating per season 2023 (111.7) |
| Andy Kauffman | Best Passing Rating per season 2026 (106.4) |
| James Ryan | Best Passing Rating per season 2036 (105.4) |
| Alton Hardman | Best Passing Rating per season 2049 (122.2) |
| Alton Hardman | Best Passing Rating per season 2053 (138.3) |
| Alton Hardman | Best Passing Rating per season 2054 (138.6) |
| Eusebio Peroff | Best Passing Rating per season 2060 (127.5) |
| John Rutledge | Best Passing Rating per season 2073 (106.3) |
| David Tscrious | Best Passing Rating per season 2077 (106.7) |
| Keith Burgess | Best Rushing Average per season2014 (4.72) |
| Justin Rodriguez | Best Rushing Average per season2019 (4.48) |
| Louis Helm | Best Rushing Average per season2021 (4.52) |
| Steven Loza | Best Rushing Average per season2022 (5.73) |
| Louis Helm | Best Rushing Average per season2023 (5.18) |
| David Sullins | Best Rushing Average per season2035 (5.18) |
| James Sandusky | Best Rushing Average per season2037 (4.51) |
| Leonard Craven | Best Rushing Average per season2073 (4.77) |
| Robert Robinson | Most receiving yards per season 2053 (1641) |
| William Hackler | Most receiving TDs per season 2025 (9) |
| David Cabido | Most receiving TDs per season 2025 (9) |
| Robert Robinson | Most receiving TDs per season 2049 (16) |
| Robert Robinson | Most receiving TDs per season 2051 (19) |
| Gregory Schorder | Best Receiving Average per season 2016 (19.5) |
| Gregory Schorder | Best Receiving Average per season 2020 (17.7) |
| William Hackler | Best Receiving Average per season 2026 (16.3) |
| David Cabido | Best Receiving Average per season 2027 (16.6) |
| Robert Morrison | Best Receiving Percentage per season 2037 (71.6%) |
| Antonio Pitcavage | Best Receiving Percentage per season 2046 (84.9%) |
| Brian Hart | Best Receiving Percentage per season 2049 (84.4%) |
| Andrew Parks | Best Receiving Percentage per season 2060 (85.9%) |
| Lloyd Hernandez | Best Receiving Percentage per season 2073 (82.9%) |